correlate Rotating Header Image

Congratulations Utah!: LJP National Champions

Congratulations to the Utes of Utah. They may not have won the BCS National Championship but I believe they’ve won something equally important, the LJP National Championship. Note, my initials are LJP.

I am one of the firm believers that until there is a playoff system, it will be more times than less where there is dispute on who is the national champion. And it lowers the value and meaning of the trophy to the right. The BCS system is arbitrary. In fact, we’d be better off using the electoral college to vote on the national champion and let the people decide. What is even more shocking: this is not an innovative idea either. Do a quick Google search on the topic, there is plenty of reading.

But in the meantime I’ve decided to hand out my own national title. And I’m handing it to the Utah Utes, the only undefeated team in the nation and the team that handed Alabama (who was #1 in the country for at least a month) a pretty convincing defeat. For those interested in statistics, the Utes received one first place vote to win the LJP National Championship title unanimously. Oklahoma received one second place vote and Texas received one third place vote.

Back to the national championship. The solution, in my mind, is quite simple: develop a 16-team playoff system and use the actual bowls to fill out the brackets. The bowls and their respective cities get their games (and profits) the nation gets one team at the end of the process that can say “we are champions”.

Quick prediction: Oklahoma defeats Florida.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • jeffbaer
    Lou--I couldn't agree more with your 16 team bracket system...NCAA football is screaming for this. The only alternative might be to eliminate the non-conference games at the beginning of each season (why does Northwestern start each year with 2 games like Rice, Duke, UNLV, Air Force???). Then each conference would likely have a clear champion by December.

    Happy 2009, buddy!

    I hope both FL and OK lose tonight. 0 - 0, with negative yards rushing and like 27 sacks.
  • Happy New Year to you! Well, early in the game, I thought your prediction was going to be more right than wrong. I like your idea about eliminating the meaningless non-conference as having clear conference champions early as possible would help. But not sure that is going to get us to where we need to be simply because no matter the number of games, there will always be a question. Who had home field advantage? The classic who lost earlier in the season? The power ranking of who lost to which school nevermind when they lost to them. There are too many inconsistencies to list out.

    My view is even if there is one team with one loss and five teams with two losses, you still need a playoff to get those teams on the field together. The decision should be made on the field with a clear line of sight to the championship.
blog comments powered by Disqus